Yes, if you're healthy, your knees can go past your toes when you squat. In a deep squat, most people's knees travel forward on their own: that's how the body keeps its balance over the feet.
If you prohibit this, the load on the knee goes down, but the load on the hip goes up, and the torso leans further forward. In one experiment, the torque at the hip, a measure of the turning effect of a load, increased more than 10-fold.
Limiting knee travel makes sense when you have pain at the front of the knee. Below are the studies, adjustments for people with different body proportions, and a step-by-step self-check.
Where the ban came from
The advice to keep your shins as vertical as possible and not let your knees go past your toes spread in the 1980s. It was based on studies from the 1970s and 1980s in which moving the knee forward increased shear forces in the knee joint and the effort of the muscles that extend the knee. Shear forces tend to shift bones relative to each other. The authors of those studies didn't look at the effects on the hip joint and the lower back, as the authors of the Illmeier 2023 review point out.
Concerns about deep squats in general, according to the authors of the Rojas-Jaramillo 2024 review, go back to Karl Klein's research in the 1960s. He assessed the stretching of knee ligaments with a device whose accuracy had never been tested.
What happens if you don't let your knees move forward
When the knees are restricted, the load shifts to the hip joint. In 2003, Fry and colleagues compared two versions of a squat to parallel, the position in which the thighs are parallel to the floor. The study included 7 trained men, and the barbell weight equaled their body weight. In one version, the knees moved freely past the toes; in the other, a wooden barrier at toe level stopped them.
They compared joint torques: the greater the torque, the harder the muscles that extend that joint are working.
| Measure | Knees go past toes | Knees stopped by barrier |
|---|---|---|
| Knee torque, N·m | 150 | 117 |
| Hip torque, N·m | 28 | 303 |
| Forward lean of torso and shin | less | more |
With the barrier, knee torque dropped by about a fifth, while hip torque increased more than 10-fold. The authors concluded that the load likely shifts to the hips and lower back, so for proper load distribution the knees may need to move slightly past the toes.
The study included only 7 people, and the torques were calculated for a static position, so what matters is the direction of the changes; the exact values can't be applied to everyone.
In 2013, List and colleagues compared trunk movement during squats with free and restricted knee travel in 30 people, using additional loads of 0, 25, and 50% of body mass. With the restriction, the thoracic spine and the segment between the lumbar and thoracic spine moved more. The authors advise coaches not to restrict forward knee travel too strictly.
Why most people's knees go past their toes
The center of mass of the body and the barbell, their combined balance point, has to stay over the feet, or you can't keep your balance. As the pelvis moves back and down, the knees move forward to counterbalance it, so in a deep squat they go past the toes in most people.
In 2010, McKean and colleagues measured knee position during the squat in 28 people, with body weight only and with an additional load of 50% of body weight. The knees went past the toes in every participant: by an average of 64–65 mm in men and 93–97 mm in women. According to the Illmeier 2023 review, in a deep squat with a shoulder-width stance and the toes turned out about 20°, most people can't avoid their knees going past their toes.
How far your knees travel depends on three things:
- Body proportions. Long thighs and a short torso send the knees further forward; a long torso and short legs, less. In Demers 2018, with 32 people squatting without added weight, relatively long thighs went with more bend at the ankle and knee, but only in narrow and medium stances. In the 2017 study by Fuglsang and colleagues, with 11 men squatting at 75% of their maximum (the heaviest weight they could squat once), no link was found between proportions and trunk lean. Greater ankle mobility was linked to a more upright torso. So the effect of proportions probably differs from person to person.
- Ankle mobility. If your foot doesn't bend well toward your shin, your knees can't move forward, and squat depth is limited. The body looks for a workaround: the knees cave inward, and the position of the spine changes.
- Load position. The further forward the load is, as in a front squat with the barbell on the front of the shoulders, the more ankle mobility you need and the further the knees travel forward.
Is it bad for the knee
The Rojas-Jaramillo 2024 review included 15 papers on deep squats and knee health: 14 showed no harm, and one, a report of a single case, linked deep squats to an injury. The authors' conclusion: with proper technique, deep squats are safe for the knee.
In 2013, Hartmann and colleagues analyzed more than 164 papers. They concluded that concerns about knee wear from deep squats are unfounded: in deep knee flexion, the pressure on the cartilage of the patella, the kneecap, is spread over a larger area.
In 2026, a randomized trial of the restriction itself was published, meaning participants were assigned to groups at random. Movahhedi and colleagues divided 60 people into three groups: squats with free knee travel, squats with restricted knee travel, and usual activity; 57 completed the study. Over 6 weeks and 18 bodyweight sessions, the restriction gave no noticeable advantage either on the scale that measures limitations due to low back pain or on the balance and jump tests. But the authors themselves call the study exploratory: the load was light, the follow-up was short, and the healthy participants had almost no limitations due to low back pain to begin with.
There is also a more cautious view. The Escamilla 2001 review advised healthy people to squat to parallel, because the forces acting on the knee increase with depth. In the author's assessment, the risk to the menisci, the cartilage pads inside the knee joint, and to the ligaments may increase. Later reviews disagree with this conclusion, but both sides have little direct data on injuries.
When to limit forward knee travel
When the front of your knee hurts. Moving the knees forward increases the load on the knee: in Fry's study, knee torque was 28% higher. In 2018, Kernozek and colleagues calculated the pressure in the joint between the kneecap and the femur in a study of 25 healthy women. When the knees went past the toes, that pressure and the effort of the quads, the muscles on the front of the thigh, were higher. In Almonroeder and colleagues, 2020, a single verbal cue to limit knee travel was enough to lower the estimated pressure in this joint.
So the choice depends on which joint matters more to offload right now. The authors of the Illmeier 2023 review consider limiting knee travel a reasonable approach during knee rehab; they don't recommend it for healthy people.
If your knee hurts when you squat, see a doctor: an article can't determine the cause of your pain.
What changes knee position in a squat
If your ankle mobility isn't enough to let your knees travel forward as you squat to the depth you need, your torso leans further forward, your knees cave inward, or the position of your back changes.
A wider stance and a heel lift reduce the demands on ankle mobility, while a load in front and a lower bar position on the back change the position of the torso and the load on the joints:
| Adjustment | What it changes | Who it suits |
|---|---|---|
| Wider stance | viewed from the side, the thigh looks shorter, and the ankle needs to bend less; a larger base of support means more stability | long thighs, limited ankle mobility |
| Heel lift or weightlifting shoes, lifting footwear with a raised heel | more upright torso, more knee bend | limited ankle mobility; possibly a focus on the quads |
| Load in front: front squat, goblet squat | more upright torso, knees travel further forward, the ankle needs to bend more | if you need an upright torso and your ankles allow it |
| Lower bar position on the back | the moment arm, the distance from the joint to the line of action of the force, is longer at the hip and shorter at the knee | if the knee needs offloading or the goal is to lift maximum weight |
Data on how the front squat distributes the load are mixed. In Krzyszkowski and colleagues, 2020, at the same weight, the front squat placed more load on the knee extensors, the muscles that straighten the leg at the knee. The back squat placed more load on the hip extensors, the muscles that extend the leg at the hip joint. At the same percentage of the maximum in each exercise, the estimated load on the knee was comparable. In Gullett and colleagues, 2009, at 70% of the maximum in each variation, knee compression and knee torque were higher in the back squat.
How I apply this with my clients
With healthy clients, I don't forbid the knees from going past the toes. I make sure the knee tracks in line with the foot and doesn't cave inward. Knee cave is a breakdown in the coordinated movement of the foot, shin, thigh, and pelvis, so we correct the movement as a whole.
Chondromalacia patellae is a softening of the kneecap's cartilage. When a doctor has made this diagnosis, I limit knee flexion to 45–60°. We work pain-free, with the quads and glutes as the priority.
I review the squat itself on video: the client sends me a recording of a set, a series of reps.
How to check your squat
- Film a working set from the side and from the front.
- From the side, check your feet: the whole foot stays in contact with the floor, and your heels don't lift.
- From the same angle, check your torso: at the bottom of a deep back squat, it's roughly parallel to your shin. This guideline comes from the Rojas-Jaramillo 2024 review.
- From the front, check your knees: they track in line with your feet and don't cave inward.
- If your heels lift, your torso drops forward, or your knees cave inward, try a wider stance or a heel lift from the table above, then film the set again and check the same points.
- Knees past your toes are normal here. In the back squat, the same review treats only excessive forward knee travel as an error: the shin should stay roughly parallel to the torso. If the front of your knee hurts, see a doctor; until then, you can reduce your depth and keep your knees from traveling far forward.
The guidelines in this article are for healthy adults. With knee injuries or knee pain, technique and load are chosen individually, together with a doctor.
If you need a plan for your goal and your gym, there's the personalized program.
Ben Patrick and knees over toes
Ben Patrick is an American coach known on social media as the Knees Over Toes Guy. His program teaches you to deliberately bring your knees past your toes in squats and lunges. The idea that the knees can go past the toes is consistent with the research above. As of September 29, 2026, no studies of the program itself were found in PubMed, the database of scientific publications.
Sources
- Illmeier G et al. The Limitations of Anterior Knee Displacement during Different Barbell Squat Techniques: A Comprehensive Review. J Clin Med, 2023. Article · Full text
- Fry AC et al. Effect of knee position on hip and knee torques during the barbell squat. J Strength Cond Res, 2003. Article
- List R et al. Kinematics of the trunk and the lower extremities during restricted and unrestricted squats. J Strength Cond Res, 2013. Article
- McKean MR et al. Quantifying the movement and the influence of load in the back squat exercise. J Strength Cond Res, 2010. Article
- Demers E et al. The Effect of Stance Width and Anthropometrics on Joint Range of Motion in the Lower Extremities during a Back Squat. Int J Exerc Sci, 2018. Article · Full text
- Fuglsang EI et al. Effect of Ankle Mobility and Segment Ratios on Trunk Lean in the Barbell Back Squat. J Strength Cond Res, 2017. Article
- Rojas-Jaramillo A et al. Impact of the deep squat on articular knee joint structures, friend or enemy? A scoping review. Front Sports Act Living, 2024. Article · Full text
- Hartmann H et al. Analysis of the load on the knee joint and vertebral column with changes in squatting depth and weight load. Sports Med, 2013. Article
- Movahhedi A et al. Unrestricted Versus Restricted Anterior Knee Displacement During Bodyweight Squat Training in Physically Active Young Adults: An Exploratory Three-Arm Randomized Controlled Trial. J Clin Med, 2026. Article · Full text
- Escamilla RF. Knee biomechanics of the dynamic squat exercise. Med Sci Sports Exerc, 2001. Article
- Kernozek TW et al. Effects of Anterior Knee Displacement During Squatting on Patellofemoral Joint Stress. J Sport Rehabil, 2018. Article
- Almonroeder TG et al. Verbal Instruction Reduces Patellofemoral Joint Loading During Bodyweight Squatting. J Sport Rehabil, 2020. Article
- Krzyszkowski J et al. Load-dependent mechanical demands of the lower extremity during the back and front squat. J Sports Sci, 2020. Article
- Gullett JC et al. A biomechanical comparison of back and front squats in healthy trained individuals. J Strength Cond Res, 2009. Article
- Hall SJ. Basic Biomechanics. 9th edition. McGraw Hill, 2022. Chapter 13: balance and stability.





