BlogArticle

Scale Not Moving During Weight Loss: Why and What to Do

Scale Not Moving During Weight Loss: Why and What to Do
  • How to tell a weight stall from normal fluctuations
  • Why your weight stalls even when you count calories
  • Whether your metabolism really slows down when you lose weight
  • What to do if your weight hasn't moved for two weeks
Contents 12 sections

If the scale isn't moving during weight loss, first check whether your weight has really stalled. Your weight changes from day to day because of water, salt, and food, so go by your average weight for the week. If your weekly average hasn't dropped in two weeks even though you're following your plan, the most common cause is untracked calories or energy expenditure that has dropped along with your weight.

Has your weight really stalled?

Your weight on a given day isn't just fat. If you ate more salt or carbs, your body held on to more water, and the scale went up even though you didn't gain any fat. Glycogen, the carbohydrate store in your muscles and liver, is stored together with water: according to Kreitzman and colleagues, every part of glycogen comes with 3–4 parts of water.

Weight also has a weekly rhythm. In 2014, Orsama and colleagues analyzed 4,657 weigh-ins from 80 adults: weight was higher on Sunday and Monday and went down toward the end of the week. The authors suggest treating these weekend-to-weekday swings as normal: they don't indicate weight gain.

In women, the menstrual cycle also affects weight. In a 2011 observational study by White and colleagues (62 women, 765 cycles), participants felt fluid retention most strongly on the first day of their period. In the days before your period and the first days of your cycle, fluid retention can mask weight loss even if you're losing fat.

How to tell a weight stall from fluctuations

Weigh yourself every morning on an empty stomach and calculate your average weight for each week. The difference between the averages of two consecutive weeks is roughly your weekly rate. A stall is when you followed your plan, but your average for the second week is no lower than for the first. One high reading after a weekend doesn't count as a stall.

In a 2015 systematic review by Zheng and colleagues (17 studies), regular self-weighing was associated with greater weight loss and was not associated with anxiety or depression. A systematic review is an analysis of studies on a single question, selected according to rules set in advance.

Why your weight stalls: five reasons

ReasonHow to tellWhat to do
Water fluctuationsweight jumps from day to day, but the weekly average goes downchange nothing, compare averages
Eating more than you logportions are eyeballed; drinks, oil, and snacks aren't loggedweigh your food and log everything
Expenditure dropped along with your weightyou've already lost a noticeable amount, and the rate slowed graduallyrecalculate your calorie target for your current weight
Less movement outside workoutsfewer steps, more sittingget back to your usual activity level
Possible recomposition: losing fat while gaining muscleyour weight isn't moving, but your waist is shrinking and your strength in lifts is going upkeep going and track your measurements

Eating more than you log

This is the most common cause. You can track all your main meals and still miss coffee with milk, juice, oil, a small piece of candy, or tasting food while cooking. Mistakes also happen when logging in an app: you picked a different food, mixed up raw and cooked weight, or entered the wrong portion size.

Research confirms this. In 1992, Lichtman and colleagues examined 10 people who considered themselves "diet-resistant": they underreported their intake by an average of 47%, and their energy expenditure was within 5% of the predicted value. Their metabolism was normal; their weight wasn't dropping because of calories that never made it into their records.

A meta-analysis is a statistical pooling of results from several studies. In a 2021 meta-analysis by McKenzie and colleagues (31 studies, 4,518 people), calorie intake was underreported with every tracking method, even in food diaries where food was weighed.

How to weigh food and what people most often forget to log is covered in the article How to Weigh Food for Calorie Counting: Raw or Cooked.

Expenditure drops along with your weight

The less you weigh, the less energy your body burns. According to the 2011 model by Hall and colleagues, the daily energy expenditure of an adult with excess weight changes by about 100 kJ (around 24 kcal) for every kilogram of body weight. Lose 10 kg, and your expenditure drops by about 240 kcal a day, so your previous deficit, the difference between what you burn and what you eat, shrinks noticeably.

That's why weight loss slows down over time and can stop even if you keep eating the same way. This kind of stall is called a plateau. Your calorie target is then recalculated for your current weight. How to do that is covered in the article How Many Calories You Need per Day to Lose Weight: How to Calculate Your Target.

Does your metabolism slow down?

Beyond the drop in expenditure caused by weight loss itself, your body may save a little more energy: this is called adaptive thermogenesis. In a 2022 systematic review by Nunes and colleagues (33 studies, 2,528 people), it was found in 27 studies. But in better-designed studies, it was smaller or statistically non-significant: the data didn't allow it to be reliably told apart from random fluctuations, and once weight stabilized, it weakened or disappeared.

In a 2020 study by Martins and colleagues, 71 people with obesity ate 1,000 kcal a day for 8 weeks. Participants lost an average of 14 kg, and their resting energy expenditure turned out to be 92 kcal a day lower than predicted. After 4 weeks without weight loss, the gap shrank to 38 kcal, and a year later it was no longer found.

Bottom line: your metabolism really does adapt, by tens of calories a day. That doesn't cancel out a deficit of several hundred calories, so when your weight stalls, look for other causes first.

Less movement outside workouts

Besides workouts, you burn energy through everyday walking, housework, and standing: this is called non-exercise activity. On a diet it can go down, but not in everyone. In a 2018 systematic review by Silva and colleagues (36 studies, 1,561 people), this kind of energy saving was found in 63% of diet-only groups, 27% of diet-plus-exercise groups, and 23% of exercise-only groups. Overall, the authors did not confirm that diet or exercise reduces non-exercise activity in healthy adults, but they point out that the studies were small and the methods outdated.

Keep an eye on your usual activity, for example with the step counter on your phone. If your step count has dropped noticeably, your expenditure has dropped with it.

Your measurements are shrinking, but your weight isn't moving

You can lose fat and build muscle at the same time: this is called recomposition. A 2020 review by Barakat and colleagues describes it in beginners and people with excess weight, as well as in trained individuals, with strength training that gradually increases the load and well-planned nutrition. In that case, your weight may change slowly even though your waist is getting smaller and you're losing fat.

That's why, in addition to your weight, you should take body measurements and photos once a week. Measure in the morning on an empty stomach, before training and before you drink any water, with the same tape, the same tension, and in the same body position. Take photos in the same lighting, hold your phone at chest level, and don't suck in your stomach.

Hormones and medical conditions

Medical conditions and hormones can slow down weight loss, but as long as you stick to a deficit, fat still comes off, just more slowly. Meanwhile, your weight may stay put for a while because of water retention. The 2017 position stand of the International Society of Sports Nutrition (ISSN) states it plainly: fat loss is driven by a sustained calorie deficit. If you have diabetes or a thyroid condition, or you take medication, including weight-loss medication, discuss your rate of loss and calorie target with your doctor. If you have an eating disorder now or have had one in the past, also discuss weighing yourself and counting calories with your doctor.

If your period is delayed or has stopped while you're in a calorie deficit, it's usually a sign that you're not getting enough energy. Raise your calories and see a doctor; cutting your food intake any further is not an option.

What to do if your weight stalls: step by step

  1. For two weeks, weigh yourself every morning on an empty stomach and calculate your average weight for each week.
  2. Check your tracking: weigh your food (it's easier raw) and make sure the entry in your app matches, raw food or cooked. Log everything: drinks, oil, sauces, snacks, tasting while cooking.
  3. Recalculate your calorie target for your current weight.
  4. Subtract your average weight for the second week from your average for the first week: that's your weekly rate in kg.
  5. Your expected rate in kg per week is roughly your daily deficit in kcal × 7 ÷ 7,700, based on the simplified rule "1 kg of fat ≈ 7,700 kcal." If your rate is less than half of what's expected and you followed your plan, lower your calorie target by no more than 10% and no more than 200 kcal at a time, then reassess after another two weeks. Two exceptions: if your period fell in the second week, wait one more week; if your waist is getting smaller, you're most likely losing fat, so leave your target alone for now.
  6. Once a week, take measurements and photos under the same conditions.

Your calorie target shouldn't drop below your basal metabolic rate, the amount of energy your body needs to sustain life at complete rest. If you'd have to eat less than that to reach the rate you want, it's better to give yourself more time.

How I work when weight stalls

When a client tells me they eat very little and aren't losing weight, I first check their tracking (snacks, sugary drinks, oil in the pan, nuts, sauces) and only then the calculation of their calorie target.

If a client follows a meal plan I've put together, after 14 days they send me their morning weigh-ins and note how closely they followed the plan; women also note whether they had their period. Based on this data, I decide:

  • the plan was broken often: I leave the target alone, and first we get back to the plan;
  • the period fell in the second week and the weight has barely moved: I change nothing and watch for another week;
  • the loss is less than half of what's expected while following the plan: I cut fat by 5–10 g and leave protein and carbs alone;
  • fat is already at 1.0 g per kg, the lower limit for fat in my meal plans: I remove about 90 kcal from carbs.

In online coaching, clients send me measurements at eight points and front, side, and back photos once a week. Weight changes with water and food, while centimeters and photos help show what has actually changed.

If a client's period is delayed while she's in a calorie deficit, I don't cut her food. I raise her calories, add 1–2 days a week with an extra 300–400 kcal from carbs, and reduce her training load.

Sources

  1. Kreitzman SN et al. Glycogen storage: illusions of easy weight loss, excessive weight regain, and distortions in estimates of body composition. Am J Clin Nutr, 1992. Article
  2. Orsama AL et al. Weight rhythms: weight increases during weekends and decreases during weekdays. Obes Facts, 2014. Article · Full text
  3. White CP et al. Fluid retention over the menstrual cycle: 1-year data from the prospective ovulation cohort. Obstet Gynecol Int, 2011. Article · Full text
  4. Zheng Y et al. Self-weighing in weight management: a systematic literature review. Obesity (Silver Spring), 2015. Article
  5. Lichtman SW et al. Discrepancy between self-reported and actual caloric intake and exercise in obese subjects. N Engl J Med, 1992. Article
  6. McKenzie BL et al. Investigating sex differences in the accuracy of dietary assessment methods to measure energy intake in adults: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Am J Clin Nutr, 2021. Article · Full text
  7. Hall KD et al. Quantification of the effect of energy imbalance on bodyweight. Lancet, 2011. Article · Full text
  8. Nunes CL et al. Does adaptive thermogenesis occur after weight loss in adults? A systematic review. Br J Nutr, 2022. Article
  9. Martins C et al. Metabolic adaptation is an illusion, only present when participants are in negative energy balance. Am J Clin Nutr, 2020. Article · Full text
  10. Silva AM et al. What is the effect of diet and/or exercise interventions on behavioural compensation in non-exercise physical activity and related energy expenditure of free-living adults? A systematic review. Br J Nutr, 2018. Article
  11. Barakat C et al. Body recomposition: can trained individuals build muscle and lose fat at the same time? Strength Cond J, 2020. Article
  12. Aragon AA et al. International society of sports nutrition position stand: diets and body composition. J Int Soc Sports Nutr, 2017. Article · Full text