BlogArticle

Training to Failure: Do You Need It for Muscle Growth?

Training to Failure: Do You Need It for Muscle Growth?
  • Whether you need to take every set to failure to build muscle
  • How failure differs from training with a few reps in reserve
  • Which exercises failure suits and where it's better to stop earlier
  • How to learn to estimate reps in reserve
Contents 9 sections

You don't need to take every set to failure to build muscle. In studies, sets that end one to three reps short of failure produce almost the same muscle growth, with less fatigue afterward.

Failure makes sense in the last set for a muscle and in simple exercises. Below: what the research shows, what failure costs you, and how to train close to it.

Failure or reps in reserve: what the meta-analyses show

Full failure has no consistent advantage. A meta-analysis pools the results of several studies. In the 2023 meta-analysis by Refalo and colleagues (15 studies), training to failure didn't produce more muscle growth than non-failure training. In the 2022 meta-analysis by Grgic and colleagues (15 studies), strength also increased equally with and without failure.

Proximity to failure does matter, though. The 2024 meta-regression by Robinson and colleagues estimated how reps in reserve relate to muscle growth using data from different studies. On average, a muscle grows more when sets end closer to failure, so sets that end far short of it produce less growth.

What failure and reps in reserve mean

Failure is the point where you can no longer complete another rep with proper technique. Reps in reserve is how many reps you have left before that point; this is also how studies define proximity to failure. Zero reps in reserve is failure; two reps in reserve means stopping two reps short of it.

Coaches abbreviate reps in reserve as RIR. The scale that links reps in reserve to a subjective rating of effort (RPE) was proposed by Zourdos and colleagues in 2016: RPE 10 corresponds to failure, RPE 9 to one rep in reserve, RPE 8 to two.

What the research shows

The studies agree on the main point: for muscle growth, it's important to get close to failure, while the last reps all the way to failure add little. In most studies, the difference between failure and training with a few reps in reserve is small or wasn't found.

The table also mentions systematic reviews: they collect studies on a single question and evaluate them using rules set in advance.

StudyWhat was comparedResult
Refalo and colleagues, 2023, meta-analysis of 15 studiesfull failure vs. non-failure trainingno advantage of failure for muscle growth
Grgic and colleagues, 2022, meta-analysis of 15 studiesfailure vs. non-failure training, strength and muscle growthno difference; in trained people, a small advantage of failure for growth
Robinson and colleagues, 2024, meta-regressiondifferent numbers of reps in reservethe closer to failure, the more muscle growth; reps in reserve had almost no effect on strength
Refalo and colleagues, 2024, 18 trained participants, 8 weeksone leg to failure, the other with 1–2 reps in reservethigh muscle thickness increased equally: by 0.181 and 0.182 cm
ACSM, 2026, overview of 137 systematic reviewstraining to failureno consistent advantage for either strength or muscle growth

The advantage of failure in trained people in Grgic's meta-analysis is small: the effect size, a measure of how large the difference is, is 0.15. For people with training experience, going right up to failure may be slightly more beneficial, but the difference is small and fatigue after failure is noticeably greater.

Robinson and colleagues estimated reps in reserve from the program descriptions in the studies and call their analysis exploratory. So it doesn't establish an exact “this many reps in reserve, this much growth” relationship.

What failure costs you

The price of failure is fatigue right after the exercise. In the 2022 meta-analysis by Vieira and colleagues (20 studies in the review, 12 in the calculations), strength and movement velocity dropped more after sets to failure. The workload felt harder during the session, and 48 hours later signs of muscle damage were more pronounced. The authors note that recovery from this kind of training may take longer.

Going to failure on every set can also hurt performance in later sets of the same workout. In the Refalo 2024 study, lifting velocity and the number of reps dropped more in sets to failure than in sets with reps in reserve. How long to rest so that the next set doesn't suffer is covered in the article How Long to Rest Between Sets for Muscle Growth.

According to a 2022 review by Refalo and colleagues, failure increases fatigue, muscle damage, and discomfort after the set. This can get in the way of recovery and reduce the desire to keep training.

When failure makes sense and when to stop earlier

A practical rule was put forward by Helms and colleagues in 2016; the authors include Zourdos, who proposed the reps-in-reserve scale. They recommend saving failure for the last set for a muscle so that fatigue doesn't reduce the number of reps in the following sets.

They recommend failure mainly for simple isolation exercises with a low risk of injury. In these exercises, movement happens at one joint. For the main lifts, such as squats and the bench press, the authors advise working mostly with 2–4 reps in reserve.

This is an expert recommendation: it's less firmly supported by data than the study findings above.

Further from failureCloser to failure or to failure
first sets for a musclelast set for a muscle
technically demanding multi-joint barbell exercises, where movement happens at several jointssimple isolation exercises, such as on machines

How to tell how many reps you have left in reserve

Estimating reps in reserve by feel isn't easy. According to the 2022 meta-analysis by Halperin and colleagues, people on average underestimate how many more reps they can do by about one. Estimates are more accurate closer to failure, with heavy weights, and in the last sets of an exercise, while training experience had almost no effect on accuracy.

In long sets of more than 12 reps, people's estimates are further off, so such a set may end further from failure than you think. How to choose the number of reps is covered in the article How Many Reps to Do for Muscle Growth and Strength.

You can check your accuracy the way Zourdos and colleagues did in 2021. During a set, make a mental note of the moment you feel you have three reps left, then one, and keep going to failure. Then compare your estimate with how many reps you actually did. The last set for a muscle in a simple machine exercise works well for this check.

In that study, participants' estimates were more accurate closer to failure and in sets with fewer reps.

How I apply this with my clients

I don't require clients to take every set to full failure: what matters is choosing how many reps to leave in reserve. In the program, each set has its reps in reserve listed, for example “RIR 2, 2, 1”: the last set is the closest to failure. The client logs the weight, the number of reps completed, and how many reps they felt they had left.

In my general physical preparation workout templates for the outdoor workout area, sets end with 2–3 reps in reserve, and the main focus is on technique.

How to apply it: step by step

Reps in reserve are chosen based on the exercise and where the set falls in the workout. Most sets end with a few reps in reserve, and failure is saved for the last set for a muscle in simple exercises. Use your recovery to check whether you're training to failure too often. The steps below work for beginners and for people who have been training for a long time.

  1. End most of your working sets with 1–3 reps in reserve.
  2. In squats, presses, and other main barbell lifts, work mostly with 2–4 reps in reserve.
  3. If the last set for a muscle falls on a simple machine exercise, you can take it to failure and use it to check how accurately you sense your reps in reserve.
  4. If you're not recovering between workouts and your working weights and reps are dropping, cut back on sets to failure.
  5. Evaluate your results over several consecutive weeks: working weights and reps in the same exercises, and your measurements.
  6. How many working sets a muscle needs per week in total is covered in the article How Many Sets per Week You Need for Muscle Growth.

The recommendations in this article are for healthy adults. Training for older people and recovery after injuries aren't covered here: with injuries or health limitations, proximity to failure and exercises are chosen individually.

If you need a plan for your goal and your circumstances, there's the personalized program.

For dosing load without burning out, see Progressive Overload and Periodization in Strength Training. To check why fatigue stalls your current plan, book a training audit.

Sources

  1. Refalo MC et al. Influence of Resistance Training Proximity-to-Failure on Skeletal Muscle Hypertrophy: A Systematic Review with Meta-analysis. Sports Med, 2023. Article · Full text
  2. Grgic J et al. Effects of resistance training performed to repetition failure or non-failure on muscular strength and hypertrophy: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Sport Health Sci, 2022. Article · Full text
  3. Robinson ZP et al. Exploring the Dose-Response Relationship Between Estimated Resistance Training Proximity to Failure, Strength Gain, and Muscle Hypertrophy: A Series of Meta-Regressions. Sports Med, 2024. Article
  4. Refalo MC et al. Similar muscle hypertrophy following eight weeks of resistance training to momentary muscular failure or with repetitions-in-reserve in resistance-trained individuals. J Sports Sci, 2024. Article
  5. Vieira JG et al. Effects of Resistance Training to Muscle Failure on Acute Fatigue: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Sports Med, 2022. Article
  6. Refalo MC et al. Towards an improved understanding of proximity-to-failure in resistance training and its influence on skeletal muscle hypertrophy, neuromuscular fatigue, muscle damage, and perceived discomfort: A scoping review. J Sports Sci, 2022. Article
  7. Currier BS et al. American College of Sports Medicine Position Stand. Resistance Training Prescription for Muscle Function, Hypertrophy, and Physical Performance in Healthy Adults: An Overview of Reviews. Med Sci Sports Exerc, 2026. Article · Full text
  8. Helms ER et al. Application of the Repetitions in Reserve-Based Rating of Perceived Exertion Scale for Resistance Training. Strength Cond J, 2016. Article · Full text
  9. Zourdos MC et al. Novel Resistance Training-Specific Rating of Perceived Exertion Scale Measuring Repetitions in Reserve. J Strength Cond Res, 2016. Article
  10. Zourdos MC et al. Proximity to Failure and Total Repetitions Performed in a Set Influences Accuracy of Intraset Repetitions in Reserve-Based Rating of Perceived Exertion. J Strength Cond Res, 2021. Article
  11. Halperin I et al. Accuracy in Predicting Repetitions to Task Failure in Resistance Exercise: A Scoping Review and Exploratory Meta-analysis. Sports Med, 2022. Article
  12. Steele J et al. Clarity in reporting terminology and definitions of set endpoints in resistance training. Muscle Nerve, 2017. Article